Every mining project passes through the same study stages before construction: a scoping study, a pre-feasibility study (PFS) and a feasibility study (FS). The terms are often used interchangeably, yet each stage answers a different question, needs different data and delivers a different level of confidence. This article sets out the differences, when each stage applies, and a fact that is rarely discussed: how often feasibility study numbers turn out to be wrong.
Three stages, three questions
A review of the engineering studies used to evaluate new mining projects concludes that the stages are progressive: each adds investigation detail, and that detail tracks directly with the value of the project (Al-Bakri et al., 2023). The simplest way to tell them apart is by the question each one answers.
- Scoping study (also called a PEA). The question: is this project worth studying further? It rests on early drilling and expert assumptions; the mine plan, processing route and costs are rough. It is enough for a quick strategic call such as keep drilling or stop, but not for an investment decision (Sterba et al., 2020; Larsen et al., 2016).
- Pre-feasibility study (PFS). The question: which option makes the most sense? Alternative mining methods, plant capacities and infrastructure are compared and one is selected. This is the stage at which resources can start to be converted to reserves under codes such as JORC and KCMI, because the modifying factors have been studied in sufficient detail.
- Feasibility study (FS, or DFS/BFS when it is prepared for bank financing). The question: can this project be financed and built? A single option is engineered in detail, capital and operating costs are built from quotations and designs, the construction schedule is set, and lenders use the document as the basis for their decision (Larsen et al., 2016).
In Indonesia the feasibility study is also a defined stage of mining activity under the mineral and coal mining law, between exploration and construction, so the document doubles as a permitting requirement rather than only an internal decision tool. Our feasibility study and mining studies services are built around exactly these stages.
Accuracy that improves step by step
The most practical difference is the accuracy range of the capital cost estimate. The ranges commonly used in industry are roughly ±30 to ±50% for a scoping study, ±20 to ±25% for a PFS and ±10 to ±15% for an FS. The exact figures vary between companies and reporting codes, but the pattern is the same: each stage narrows the uncertainty, and the cost of the study rises steeply with the detail involved.

What happens after the feasibility study
This is the part that is rarely discussed. A study of 63 international mining and smelting projects found that as-built capital costs were on average 14% higher than the bankable feasibility study estimate. Roughly half of the projects fell outside the ±15% range the FS had promised, and about one in thirteen overran by 100% or more. The authors found little attenuation of this bias over time; it persists, they argue, because project sponsors need attractive economics to secure financing (Bertisen and Davis, 2008).
More recent findings point the same way. An analysis of four copper project technical reports recommends that Competent Persons be extremely conservative with the precision ranges and contingencies applied at each stage (Suárez Nieto et al., 2024). At the front-end engineering (FEED) stage, construction cost overruns on mining projects are reported at 25 to 37%, with leading causes that include impractical schedules, inadequate feasibility studies, client pressure to minimise initial capital, and poorly understood geology and geotechnics (Shafaay et al., 2025).
Three of those four causes are not engineering problems. They are problems of honest numbers at the study stage.
What is changing in study practice
- Results are reported as ranges. More studies now model geological uncertainty with many realisations and report NPV as P10/P50/P90 rather than a single figure. Recent decision-support systems evaluate hundreds of thousands of scenarios at once and report a P10–P90 risk envelope (Rahimi, 2025). The same shift applies to resource estimation, as we discussed for nickel laterite.
- Closure costs are counted from the start. In ESG due diligence across hundreds of mine sites, revised closure cost estimates almost invariably exceeded the provisions in corporate reports, feasibility studies and NI 43-101 documents (Leahy and Farrer, 2023). Rehabilitation and closure are therefore now expected in the option selection of the earliest studies, not at the end of mine life (Tomlin and Gimber, 2023).
- Flexibility is valued. DCF compresses every uncertainty into one NPV. Real options analysis values the choice to defer, expand or abandon; for an Indonesian coal project it has been tested with carbon pricing and energy transition scenarios (Trijayanto and Hakam, 2025).
Which study, when
- Early drilling only, deciding whether to continue: scoping study. Do not use its numbers to raise money.
- Several design options, and you want to declare reserves: PFS. This is the minimum stage for converting resources to reserves.
- Bank financing, board approval or permitting documents: FS. Ask for the accuracy range and contingency to be stated explicitly, and compare them with the overrun statistics above before trusting a single NPV.
- At any stage: ask for results as ranges, make sure closure costs sit in the period cash flow, and check whether the geological understanding supports the accuracy being claimed.
Study stages are not just a sequence of documents. They are the industry admitting that certainty is bought in instalments, and that the single number on the summary page always has a range behind it. If you are preparing a study or reviewing one before an investment, our due diligence and project review team can help.
References
Al-Bakri, A. Y., Ahmed, H. M., Ahmed, H. A. M. and Hefni, M. A., 2023. Evaluation studies of the new mining projects. Open Geosciences. https://doi.org/10.1515/geo-2022-0466
Bertisen, J. and Davis, G. A., 2008. Bias and error in mine project capital cost estimation. The Engineering Economist. https://doi.org/10.1080/00137910802058533
Larsen, D., Addison, R., Kehmeier, R. and Swendseid, T., 2016. Minimum engineering requirements for assessing mining projects. Minerals & Metallurgical Processing. https://doi.org/10.19150/mmp.6842
Leahy, K. and Farrer, G., 2023. Sustainable finance and the role of mine closure. Proceedings of the International Conference on Mine Closure. https://doi.org/10.36487/acg_repo/2315_085
Rahimi, I., 2025. A decision support system for open-pit mining optimisation with dynamic uncertainty and GPU-based parallel repair approach. Expert Systems with Applications. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eswa.2025.129544
Shafaay, M. A., Alqahtani, F. K., Alsharef, A. and Chen, G., 2025. Modeling construction cost overrun risks at the FEED stage for mining projects using PLS-SEM. Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering. https://doi.org/10.1080/13467581.2025.2481242
Sterba, J. et al., 2020. Energy-sustainable industrialized growth in the Czech Republic: The Cínovec lithium mining project. Resources Policy. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2020.101707
Suárez Nieto, L., Fidalgo Valverde, G., Krzemień, A. and Riesgo Fernández, P., 2024. Economic risks in mining investments: A prospective analysis of capital cost estimation in copper mining projects. Resources Policy. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2024.105427
Tomlin, C. and Gimber, C., 2023. Meaningful evaluation of rehabilitation and closure in the early stages of the mine life cycle. Proceedings of the International Conference on Mine Closure. https://doi.org/10.36487/acg_repo/2315_099
Trijayanto, T. and Hakam, D. F., 2025. Economic viability and flexibility of the South Pasopati Coal Project, Indonesia: A real options approach under market volatility and carbon pricing. Journal of Risk and Financial Management. https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm18050225


